Feb 26, 2021
This past week, I obtained a copy
of Sia's movie Music, taking her up on her tweeted request to watch
the film before judging it. Released clips aside, I went into it
with expectations based on its description and promotion. Below are
real-time notes with time-stamps as proof of screening.
This dissection cannot and does not
cover everything, with selections focused on specific and
problematic depictions of autism, autism treatments, parents and
caregivers, ableist tropes and other issues I felt could not be
ignored. I watched this with a friend whose insights are included
with my own.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
00:00:51 - Music
starts its first shot of Music (played by Maddie Ziegler) in her
underwear, getting dressed. It's an...odd way to start the film
considering the descriptions and trailers that have been
released.
Not a sexualized shot,
but...uncomfortable. Why is this the opening shot? What purpose
does it serve?
Music puts on her pants and then
starts hitting her thigh with a closed fist; why? Does she not like
the clothing? No answer.
00:01:20 - First
music video (song performance) and the imitation of autistic stims
and behaviors begins, with twitching, blinking, and hand
motions/stilted fingers; wide eyes and open mouth with upper teeth
jutted out. Overwhelming colors and strobe light effects (not as
intense as your local haunted house, but very much there). Not sure
what this performance at this time is supposed to represent, but
the song at least gives context clues; something about how her mind
isn't in control of her body.
00:03:26 - aaand
suddenly Music is back in reality, but also back in bed!...wait,
wasn't she just getting dressed and standing up? Maybe we're doing
the whole ‘Chicago’ route with musical numbers representing what
the character is thinking?
Humming and the same upper teeth
jutted out. Not Ziegler's fault, but you can tell it's not
natural.
00:05:30 - After a
non-contextual scene with Music and what appears to be
her....mom...?, Music has breakfast, has her hair braided and then
leaves on her own accord. Not great, but so far not
terrible.
00:05:34 - Toe
walking! Starting to think that I should've brought my Autism Bingo
card from Giraffe Party, because I have a feeling there's going to
be an awful lot of autism tropes in this film, with a focus on
infantilization.
Man running newspaper stand gives
Music pictures of dogs (assorted). Normally this would be kind of
sweet, but likely this is a not-so-subtle hint at one of Music's
‘special interests’.
Who's this guy in the green and
white striped polo paying for the watermelon slice that the vendor
hands to Music? I applaud the coordination here but this doesn't
feel right.
...wait, is the entire neighborhood
in on watching her? So she wasn't just leaving of her own accord on
her own? NEED CONTEXT.
00:06:00 - Music
visits the library, and if the newspaper stand guy's torn-out dog
pictures weren't enough of a clue, Music explores a book about dogs
on a shelf.
So far, all we know about Music
is:
- Girl
- Interested in Dogs (What kind?
Favorite? No clue)
- Lives with parent?
- Has headphones and wears them, but
no idea if she's listening to anything
00:07:07 - Entire
veneer of ‘autistic girl’ is dropped as Music seems to stare off
into the sun. No jutting teeth, mouth closed, eyes no longer wide,
a very calm and almost meditative expression.
Why is th-OPE NEXT SCENE!
Back to the ...mom...?, where we
find out that her conversation topics come from popsicle sticks.
Okay, but is this implying that Music cannot read? We just came
from the library, but was she just looking at pictures?
Maybe the next scene or two will
enlighten us.
00:07:47 - Music is
no longer staring at the sun, but the ...mom...? is having trouble!
Something is wrong!
Back and forth between Music and her
mom, with Music performing all the autism tropes as she walks down
the street. The same neighbors are there but at least they're not
giving her baby-talk; talking AT her, yes - but no
baby-talk.
MOM IS HAVING A STROKE....I
THINK!
00:09:06 - The
‘mother’ has fallen down and looks at the very least unconscious.
Music doesn't seem to notice this at first, taking her seat at the
kitchen table as though nothing was out of the ordinary. Yet
another autism trope that seems to indicate autistics don't ‘read
the room’, which is at best incorrect.
A few seconds later as the building
landlord comes in, Music indicates she IS aware something is wrong
with her ‘mom’. Music seems to be at the beginnings of a meltdown
and starts hitting herself.
00:09:43 - “Don't
worry Music, she's just sleeping!” More infantilization.
00:10:10 - ‘Mom’ is
dead, being hauled out in a bodybag on a gurney. Music seems upset,
which is expected.
What's NOT expected is this neighbor
saluting her body as it passes by his door. Why is he saluting? Is
he former military? Was she? Can we get some context
please?!?
No one is talking to her, just at
her - and now no one is talking to her at all. A police officer and
the landlord talk about her in front of her like she's not in the
hallway.
Okay so now what hap-
00:10:40 - Scene
change! It's Zu (Kate Hudson) in smiley-face knee socks snoozing in
a folding chair! Might be AA or rehab, but we again don't quite
know. Takes a phone call - her grandma died. I assume that's
Music's motherly figure that just died, so that's her grandmother
as well...?
00:13:39 - Zu's
character arc begins as she enters Music's apartment, having a
coarse conversation with George the landlord. Clearly the movie is
trying to make us hate Zu so that we can watch as she
is...transformed...by Music.
00:14:19 - “I'm
goin' home. Rough day.” Probably the most enjoyable line in the
movie so far.
00:14:52 - Hard to
criticize because I assume this is supposed to demonstrate how NOT
to treat an autistic, but still cringey watching Zu take off
Music's headphones without permission and try and force eye
contact.
OOOHHHH ZU IS MUSIC'S OLDER
SISTER!
00:15:15 - Zu calls
L.A. Dept of Mental Health and asks “Do you do pickup?”, starting
an exchange which is slightly funny, especially due to the
unfortunate fact that it's highly likely social services in
multiple states has had this same conversation. The realism splits
away when the person on the other end of the line hangs up on Zu,
which is very much against Dept of Mental Health rules in any
state.
00:15:28 - Her name
is Kazu. Her NAME. IS KAZU.
MUSIC and KAZU.
Is this some sort of nod to Frank
Zappa's children? Is Frank the father?
(sighs)
Well at least we see the will -
excuse me, The Big Book Of Music, with glitter and stickers. The
letter written to Zu isn't much better, apparently with no
information about Music's schedule, accommodations and needs. No
case worker, no service coordinator - Music is left in the care of
her sister and...that's it?
00:17:10 - That guy
with the green and white striped polo is shining a flashlight into
Music's window from across the street as she's settling down to
sleep. Another music video starts; a sad song but...happy
face??
Is he her friend? Who IS this guy?
Why is he doing this? Music is faced away from the window, he can't
see her reactions, so why does he shine a flashlight into her
window?
Strobe effect as he turns it on and
off. Again, no context for this.
What's with the dog? Does the dog
represent the special interest or someth-
00:19:10 - Scene
change, keep up audience, it's morning! Second underwear shot, but
Zu this time.
Music comes in to a sleeping Zu, and
says quietly, “make you eggs” twice, then YELLS it - more echolalia
but not explained to the audience. Was the breakfast routine not
mentioned in the Big Book Of Music?
Zu cooks some eggs, then Music says
“braid your hair”. Zu replies, “I don't have hair” - which doesn't
follow the context clue of “make you eggs”, so either Zu isn't
listening, or is just being a jerk.
00:20:15 - Music
goes from saying “braid your hair” to full-on autism imitation
meltdown in literal seconds, a clear attempt by the movie to scare
the audience into thinking Music is violent and unstable. Zu was
responding, talking to Music, but that doesn't seem to prevent it
(which is not in line with actual autistic meltdowns).
Now, if the eggs were done
incorrectly and other factors weren't taken into account, a
meltdown would make sense - but we don't get that context. Instead
we get Music hitting herself, throwing off her headphones (which
goes against assumptions made about Music and...well, music being a
calming stim for her) and hitting Zu.
Third underwear shot, Zu again! Why,
pray tell, do we get a butt shot of Zu in her underwear in this
scene? What purpose does it serve? We already know she's only
wearing it. No need for this shot.
00:20:43 - Saluting
neighbor (Leslie Odom Jr.) makes another appearance after knocking
on the door of the apartment, and Zu just letting him barge
in.
Uh, hi, who the hell are you, and
why did Zu just let you in?
We're not told, but he immediately
walks in and grabs Music, picks her up and then pins her to the
ground.
Odom: “I'm going to compress you and
make you feel safe”
Zu: “You're hurting her!”
Odom: “No I am not, I am crushing
her with my love”
Zu: “...oh okay”
Wasn't this one of two scenes of
restraint that were supposed to be REMOVED from this movie, Sia?
Wasn't there an outcry about how WRONG and UNETHICAL and HARMFUL it
is to portray this kind of restraint as an autism treatment to
audiences?
“Crushing her with my love” is how
autistic kids get hurt or even killed, not comforted or
de-escalated. This is NOT - I repeat, NOT - help an autistic child
become more calm; on the contrary, restraint ESCALATES the
meltdown.
00:21:30 - Ah,
Leslie Odom's character is named Ebo. Finally we get a name after
traumatizing Music with restraint, and all she wanted was her hair
braided, not to be aggressively pinned down.
And now we know grandma's name -
Millie.
Ebo's not a case worker, not a
service coordinator - just a neighbor that tackles her and pins her
down. At least the film isn't depicting a trained professional
doing this.
00:23:13 -
Apparently we've gone back in time, as meltdowns are called
‘episodes’ by this film. I wonder what other widely-used terms in
the autism and autistic communities have been swapped out for what
Sia has written in?
Great research, Sia. Even Autism
$peaks uses the term meltdown.
Also another underwear shot of Zu -
number four.
00:23:55 - Zu: “Her
whole life's a schedule” Uh, everyone's life is a schedule; this
isn't a new concept - most people schedule their lives, either
through a to-do list or a calendar.
At least Ebo seems to expect Music
to have autonomy, despite admitting that, yes, the entire
neighborhood coordinates around Music every day.
Ebo then reveals he had a younger
brother who he also restrained the same way when he was having a
meltdo- excuse me, ‘episode’.
00:24:31 - BEST
UNINTENTIONAL JOKE OF THE FILM:
Ebo: “He liked to be held to feel
safe”
Zu: “Where is he now”
Ebo: “...He is dead now”
DID HE SUFFOCATE WHILE BEING PINNED
DOWN?
Ebo: “Special needs are not
well-understood by my country. In fact, in my village, it was
considered a curse”
I feel like I need to apologize to
Ghana for this borderline xenophobic line. I don't know the level
of care for disabled persons in Ghana, but I'm sure this is a gross
simplification at least.
This writing is seriously
godawful.
00:25:26 -
Bed-wetting reference, yet another autism trope. Zu confesses to
wetting the bed four months prior in comparison to Music not
wetting the bed in over two years.
People do this to autistics all the
time, so while it's not surprising to see in the film, it's
disappointing. “Oh, you have [issue]? I have that too! We're all a
little autistic!"
00:25:56 -
SERIOUSLY WHO IS THIS GUY IN THE GREEN AND WHITE STRIPED POLO
FOLLOWING MUSIC AROUND?!?
00:27:00 - NOW HE'S
CHANGED SHIRTS?!?
00:27:15 - This is
the first time I've heard the term ‘people pound’. Is that actually
a term people use?
At least Odom's reaction is the same
one I had in response.
00:27:58 - The
green/white striped polo guy finally gets some focus; apparently he
works with his family at the dry cleaners. Yes, his parents are
Asian, and yes, we've once again flirted with borderline racism.
The dad wonders aloud why they adopted him.
Found out his name's Felix, but
that's only after turning on the subtitles. When would the movie
have told me otherwise? It's a mystery.
00:30:06 - We're
back at the apartment and it's nighttime. Zu digs through a closet
and finds some childhood stuff (toys, clothing, etc), and in the
excitement runs back in and bothers Music - who's watching a
show.
Zu immediately turns it off in a
demand for Music's attention, with little regard to Music's time,
preferences or even consent. I know it's just a TV show, but try
doing this with your friends or someone you love and see how they
take it.
00:30:39 - Music
apparently has seizures!
Zu, recalling her dead dog Raindrop,
mentioned it had seizures ("Just like you, Music").
Adding to the list, along with
echolalia and other symptoms. So the flashlight and the whole
‘crushing with love’ thing are even MORE dangerous than initially
perceived.
00:31:02 - More
backstory. Apparently their (Zu and Music's) mom was a drug addict
and carelessly left the door open, and the dog Raindrop got hit by
a car.
Music, sticking to her schedule,
leaves to go to bed, but Zu fails to recognize the time and again
respect Music. The film makes Music look disinterested, not
listening, not caring instead of framing Zu as the problem
here.
00:31:30 - Zu's at
a wig shop...? OH my mistake, it's a drug dealer's place. A creepy
drug dealer that refuses to acknowledge boundaries, but with good
intentions and half-assed flamboyance. This is where we also find
out what Zu does for money - she deals prescription
drugs.
Yet another underwear shot. We're at
5.
00:34:07 - LOOK
EVERYONE, A SIA FILM IN A SIA MOVIE - SIA-CEPTION!
00:36:02 - Ebo is
shown on the phone desperately trying to procure some sort of
medication; apparently he has some sort of medical condition, but
we don't get to know or find out. Is he...diabetic? Does he
have...MS? Surely whatever he has won't be a stereotype of his skin
color!
Next day Music and Ebo are seen,
with Music learning to utilize an AAC tablet. She hits “I am sad”,
which prompts Ebo to respond with dismissal and instructing her to
hit “I am happy”. This isn't how you teach such usage.
00:36:15 [roughly]
- Finally get to a scene that's used in the trailer - the kiddie
pool scene.
Ebo to Zu, leaning out the window:
“What are you doing, sister?”
...seriously, this is some dogshit
writing.
Zu to Ebo: “I'm
CELEBRATING!”
What are we celebrating? Why? No
idea, and the film wastes none of its time explaining the
details.
But at least Music finally gets the
chance to communicate her wants/desires/feelings. Progress,
right...?
00:37:07 - In a
rare moment of autonomy and respected decision-making, Music's
given a choice, and Ebo not only addresses her directly to ensure
consent - he also defends and reinforces her decision against Zu's
unceasing persuasions and requests.
It took over 30 minutes, but there
it is: a tiny, tiny bright spot in this film.
00:40:39 - FELIX IS
IN THE BOXING GYM!
Another disability trope: pretending
to put the disabled person ‘in charge’ or, in Music's case, “sit
here and let the fighters know what they're doing
wrong”.
00:41:34 - Poster
of Ebo's boxing days hangs on the wall. We finally learn what his
last name is.
Odom. Ebo's last name is Odom. You
know, like the actor...Leslie Odom Jr.
If this is the only main character
in the film that shares the same name with the actor, it's going to
be very hard to not see this as vaguely racist. Was it that hard to
not give him a different last name?
00:42:01 - The film
continues to bait & switch on acceptance/understanding and ableism,
where it will get SO FUCKING CLOSE to understanding, but each time
takes a hard turn just before getting there.
Ebo states Music may want to change,
but “can't change”, as in being autistic. An acknowledgment of the
fact that Music is and will always be autistic, but doesn't
differentiate disability from personal growth.
Ebo: “Each change comes with a
barrage of new stimuli." YES! Correct! This is true!
“The headphones. It's called audio
filtering” *facepalm* No it isn't, no one - not autistics, not
academics, not even Autism $peak$ calls it that. Seriously, not
part of the terms they use.
“Her hearing is so sensitive she can
hear whispering up to two rooms away." Ooookay, this may be true
but is devoid of context that would explain that, as an autistic
with such hearing, you pick up EVERYTHING - even stuff others
cannot hear.
For many of us, we can't just pick
and choose what comes through.
“She can understand everything you
are saying to her.” Again, yes! Thank you! Presumption of
competence!
“Maybe not right then. How it works
is she hears it, she files it away, and then sometimes it is
returned to her main system three weeks later.”
WHAT THE FUCK ARE YOU TALKING
ABOUT?!? No. Incorrect. That's not how that works AT
ALL.
Where the hell are these definitions
and claims coming from? I'm not a fan of Autism $peak$ but even
THEY don't spew this level of bullshit.
“You know how she looks at you, and
then looks away quickly?” Oh no, where is this going? Please be
about eye contact, PLEASE be about eye contact...
“She has taken a snapshot.” OH COME
ON SERIOUSLY
“If she didn't look away, it would
totally overwhelm her.” Right conclusion, absolutely wrong
reasoning.
3 years of research and this is what
Sia gives us.
00:44:00 - Hey,
remember that restraint scene in the park so many of us were
justifiably upset about? Yep, still in the film. You know, despite
the fact that Sia said she was removing it.
Music is overwhelmed by a group of
noisy kids running past, and starts hitting herself, taking off her
headphones and tablet.
Zu: “Come on Ebo do that thing.”
That thing, by the way, is what was done at 00:20:43.
Ebo: “I'm not climbing on top of a
small screaming white girl in the middle of this park." Oh, so Zu's
going to be the one ‘crushing’ Music with her love.
Zu pins Music to the ground, face
down. Despite the fact that they're in a park, there's room to
move, and letting Music move through being overwhelmed would be a
safer alternative.
Ebo:“Tell her she's safe” No, that's
not how this works.
Watching this just makes me feel
exhaustively sad.
The technique used by Zu isn't safe,
it wouldn't make ME feel safe, and the way she's wrenching her
arms, it's likely causing damage.
There's a major difference between
feeling safe by being confined (squeeze boxes, weighted blankets,
etc) and being pinned down.
00:45:30 - After
the restraint Music is given a snow cone and apparently everything
is just fine.
Now back at the apartment, we get
more of the ‘playful’ flirting, with Ebo telling Zu she's closer to
her autistic sister in emotional age in contrast to actual age. How
old is Music? How old is Zu? If this film mentions either, they've
both been forgotten.
Zu then calls Raindrop her spirit
animal, because of course she does.
00:47:42 -
Apartment gets hit by a blackout. Ebo tells Zu about his failed
marriage and how his wife is marrying his brother (not the autistic
one, he's dead, remember?). There's apparently more, but despite a
blackout, Ebo's holding the rest for later.
Hey, where's Music? Oh, just
chillin' out on the couch with her tablet. It's a wonder she was
visually even in this scene, like an accessory of Zu.
00:51:04 - Next
morning, Zu is at a pawn shop talking about relationships. Arguably
the best character in the film, the Pawn Shop guy, makes a brief
appearance, and says “If I didn't know any better I would swear
that you were coming to me for love advice."
If you have to watch any portion of
this film, this is probably the least problematic and most
well-acted part. It lasts 14 seconds. You're welcome.
00:52:05 - After a
brief scene of Zu and Music laughing over a table (don't ask why,
you won't find out), Ebo's at his gym, making children flinch for
some reason after giving some odd speech.
00:52:21 - It's
Felix again! Ebo talks to him, calls him an artist - Picasso -
which, again, makes no sense without CONTEXT.
00:52:56 - Felix
leaves the gym and happens upon some sort of dance exercise class.
Then he watches dancing at home, so now it's clear that Felix would
rather dance than box. I assume that Felix will be one of the many
characters that Music will magically transform (using her
inspiration) into the dancer he so desperately wants to
be.
His dad tells him he's got a big
fight tomorrow, but his mom slips him a note that reads: “I love
you, keep going”.
FINALLY the plot is beginning to be
established. 50 minutes in.
00:54:18 - Music is
literally set dressing, as the film tries to really force this
romance between Zu and Ebo. What's she creating? The film doesn't
show you, and thinks you won't care. She's out of focus and off to
the side.
Zu is singing a lullaby written by
her grandmother about Music. Now's the time for a music video, but
it never comes; unfortunate because this seems obvious.
Ebo keeps calling Zu ‘sister’, and
it makes us very uncomfortable.
00:56:20 - Speaking
of Ebo, he got an invite to his ex-wife's wedding, where she's
marrying Ebo's brother - and he's going to attend! Is he going to
stop the wedding? Start a fight? Disown his brother?
Nope, it's to ‘wish him
well’.
Zu then decides “We're going to be
your dates” - and by ‘we’ she means her and Music. Music apparently
has no agency and is not allowed to voice her objections to
attending.
00:57:23 - Watching
her with envy because we can't do the same, Music gets up and
leaves for bed, as usual for her personal routine.
Zu: “I think she's trying to tell us
something.” Yeah, that she's going to bed, not trying to help you
get laid.
What is Music, the Hunchback from
Disney's Hunchback of Notre Dame?
00:58:46 - Leslie
Odom Jr. finally sings in a very confusing music video with big-ass
suspenders and pants, and....a bible coffin? What does the bible
have to do with this? I get Ebo is sad but it still feels very
obtuse and nebulous.
Zu falls asleep and Ebo leaves the
apartment. No one gets laid.
01:00:59 - Zu tries
to palm Music off onto the landlord George because she has to go do
work or something. Is Music okay with that? We don't know, as Music
once again is little more than scenery.
01:01:12 - Zu,
taking Music with her to a drug deal: “Can we try not to have one
of your freak-outs up there, all right?”
So now instead of calling meltdowns
‘episodes’ like the film did earlier, they're now ‘freak-outs’.
Lovely.
01:01:45 - In the
most unrealistic drug deal ever conceived, Zu manhandles Music when
she gets into various art pieces, and eventually sits her down on a
couch.
01:02:16 - No.
Noooo. No No NO WAY. ARE YOU KIDDING ME?!?
Zu: “Is that a Sia wig?”
Is Sia seriously this vain to star
in her own fucking film?!?
At least Stan Lee had the
thoughtfulness to always be an extra where you had to TRY and find
him. Something tells me that's not happening here.
01:02:22 - That
something was correct.
Sia: “Drug Dealer, is that
you?”
That line alone is bad - almost
campy if you squint your ears - but what follows is either the most
brilliant idea by the most stereotypical stoner, or the jankiest
and overly obvious duct-taped scenario to have Sia star in her own
movie.
Sia explains that she's not buying
the drugs for a party, no - she's buying them to deliver via her
private plane to Haiti. Due to the earthquake, the Haitian
children's bones were dislocated; due to a combination of red tape
and inability of even the Red Cross to get there, they barely have
acetaminophen.
Sia's solution is to fly illegally
obtained prescription drugs to Haiti to use on children.
She calls it “Popstars without
borders”.
There is not enough room here to
unpack how batshit this is - but honestly a more interesting plot
than this entire film.
01:03:25 - We turn
back to Music, and in yet another autism trope, the candies from
the large bowl on the coffee table have been laid out in lines
separated by color.
01:03:48 - Another
music video; the lyrics seem to be the main statement of what Sia's
trying to say with this film. The implied message is that autistics
are ‘magical’ and that Sia's love will make us ‘sparkle’ and
‘shine’.
She's trying to be positive but
fails to understand WHY this is a problem.
01:06:30 - Back at
the drug dealer's place, Zu gets handed a package of Triomune, some
anti-HIV drug, to deliver to someone.
Bet it's to Ebo, because of course
it is. The mysterious illness is HIV.
Why. WHY. WHY IS THIS FILM GIVING
THE ONLY CHARACTER FROM THE CONTINENT OF AFRICA HIV?!?
At this point, how can we NOT call
this film both ableist AND racist?
Please, SIa, prove me wrong, don't
make Ebo be HIV positive.
01:08:11 - Yep, Ebo
has HIV.
Zu seems to deliver the package, but
then just...leaves. No one says anything. No explanation, no
understanding, no resolution.
At the very least it doesn't seem to
be homophobic, so the film has that going for it.
01:09:23 - Zu and
Music are back in the park, and they stop for snowcones. As Zu
orders the snowcones, we see Music get down on her back and eat gum
off of the bottom of a park bench. Despite the fact that the movie
has told us Sia has gum in her fanny pack she wears.
Why are we shown this? Why does Sia
want people to think autistics pick gum from the bottom of
benches?
Zu demands Music spit it out into
her hand as though Music were a dog.
01:10:26 - So
apparently the bench gum-eating was a setup for Music to get stung
by a bee, which as we were told earlier in the film, Music is
allergic to bee stings. Zu doesn't seem to remember, but FINALLY
SOME CONTINUITY!
Zu decides the best thing to do is
to carry her to the hospital instead of calling an
ambulance.
01:11:00 - Ebo's
holding his child boxing tournament, and Felix is in it. Apparently
Felix really doesn't want to fight, and instead of fighting he
just...hugs the other kid. They both seem to start crying - do ANY
of the kids in this thing want to box?!?
01:12:03 -
Apparently Music had an epipen in her fanny pack. Oh, and Zu left
her drugs behind at the park, which sends Zu into a panic. Zu
tosses stuff around, screams, hits herself - but no one pins her to
the floor to calm her down.
01:13:26 - Music's
first unprompted, unguided use of her AAC device, telling Zu she's
scared. Instead of acknowledging it, Zu responds with “We're all
scared, Music”.
01:19:00 - Felix is
seen applying for a service dog; his parents are arguing loudly.
Suddenly his dad becomes very violent and hits him while choking
his mom - and he falls back, hits his head on the floor and
dies.
What the hell? Felix didn't get one
single word and gets killed off? What's the point in this seemingly
unnecessary death?
This is getting dark, and not in a
good way.
01:21:10 - Oh, at
least Felix gets a music video. And his suit matches the wallpaper.
He dances with Music, then he and Music's grandmother (yes, she's
also dead) ride in some sort of pedicab.
Then, for some reason, he puts a
blanket over Zu as she falls asleep on the couch (after Zu got
drunk and hurt herself), despite not being alive. I'm confused and
sad but for all the wrong reasons, and I'm just exhausted with this
film.
It's clear that this is NOT a film
about autism, nor really about an autistic named Music.
01:28:25 - Another
music video mixed with regular film shots; small clip of Music
possibly having another meltdown, but it's implied that Zu is able
to calm her down without pinning her to the ground.
The montage seems to be wrapping up
the film, but we don't get much of any resolution (what about the
drug dealer who lent the pills to Zu for that ‘popstar without
borders’? Speaking of, did they ever get to Haiti with the pain
meds for the kids with dislocated limbs? Is Felix's dad arrested
for involuntary manslaughter? We'll never know!)
01:30:04 - Yet
ANOTHER depicted meltdown of Music, with a LOT of Zu being hit. How
many more of these scenes are we going to get?
The montage continues and it feels
like we're having to make up for lost time somewhere; scenes fly by
with little explanation, and the audience just has to make up its
own mind rather than follow the story.
We've lost count of how often we see
Zu in her underwear.
01:30:56 - Due to
having relapsed and only recently getting clean - and realizing
she's not a good caregiver - Zu hints at needing to get Music ‘used
to the facility’ before she leaves during a farewell conversation
with the landlord. So Music's going to the people pound, I
guess?
Oh, and despite alluding to him
knowing Music for years, he doesn't even say goodbye to her - or
acknowledge her presence. Music could've physically been absent
from the scene and it wouldn't have changed.
01:32:06 - We see
the facility, which looks like a nursing home or hospital wing. I'm
hedging my bets that the budget for the film was running low at
this point instead of the assumption that Sia doesn't know what
group homes or other assisted living facilities for disabled
persons looks like.
01:33:09 - As Zu is
unpacking Music's things (does Music know she's being moved here?),
Music says “Don't go” - the first thing she's said that isn't
echolalia. Then Music reaches out and grabs Zu's dog pendant (in
honor of Raindrop) and says again, “Sis don't go”.
Despite not establishing at all that
Zu genuinely cares about her sister beyond ensuring she stays
alive, the film pretends that it has, and that this moment is
supposed to be really sweet and vulnerable - but it comes off so
fake, so infantilizing, so...plastic.
01:34:11 - IT'S A
BREAKOUT! Zu busts open the double doors of the hospit - sorry,
facility - with Music in tow. It's way too dramatic, since Music
wasn't locked in or restrained there, and Zu hadn't
left.
Where are they going? Why, to Ebo's
brother's wedding, of course!
01:34:30 - Yep, the
budget is running out - this wedding seems to be hosted at a local
motel that got a great deal on a surplus amount of wallpaper. The
wedding itself is...minimally decorated, but does have the Ghanaian
national flag on the wall - because all weddings feature the
couple's origin country flag, right?
Ebo is wearing a tuxedo, but the
newly married couple is dressed in garb that strongly hints of a
google search using the words ‘traditional Ghana wedding'. He's
giving a speech as the film builds to its climax.
01:35:51 - Zu and
Music burst into the Motel 6 conference room and interrupt Ebo's
speech.
Zu tells Ebo: “I almost gave Music
away to strangers today.” Like she's some sort of object, not a
person.
She continues: “I'm gonna help her
like she helped me.” HOW DID SHE HELP YOU, ZU? You just told Ebo
that ever since you busted your face falling down drunk, ever since
that night, you've been clean and sober. What part did Music play
in your rehabilitation?
01:37:00 - “We
should do the song”, Zu says to Ebo, referring to the lullaby from
earlier in the film. Why not, you've already crashed the wedding,
and until Ebo introduced you, no one in attendance was really
paying attention anymore.
01:37:25 - Ebo
starts to play the song, and before Zu sings, guess who's finally
singing?
Yep, Music. In a very quiet, shy,
barely audible way. Everyone in the audience is smiling and/or
nodding their heads. One would think there would be
more....diversity of emotion when a wedding is crashed, but clearly
we're just mistaken.
I wonder where Sia got the
inspiration for this scene: an assumed non-speaking autistic child,
suddenly singing to a crowd rapt with attention and praise - ah,
yes, the ‘research’ of watching the numerous videos of this same
situation strewn across the web!
01:39:00 (roughly)
- After a fade to black, we fade in to a morning with Zu, Ebo and
Music. There's a knock at the door! Who could it be? Why, it's a
delivery for....
Music Gamble!
It's a service dog! Felix was
ordering a service dog for Music - right before he was
killed!
No one questions the delivery, no
one steps in to assist in orientation for how this dog is to be
utilized - just YAY A DOG MUSIC LIKES DOGS HAHAHAHA HAPPY
ENDING
The film ends with one final music
video where the entire cast comes together to dance the end credits
out.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
There's a lot to discuss here - and
all of it will be brought up in the next podcast episode, to be
released very soon - but one thing surprised me the most about this
film:
It's not about autism, and it's
really not even about Music.
Despite being promoted, packaged and
even described as a movie about an autistic girl, Music is
inconsequential to this film's plot. I was expecting typical
entertainment ableism and all its tropes; I was expecting, as Sia
described it, “Rain Man the musical, but with girls” - and was
absolutely denied that in my viewing.
Rare does a movie disappoint me, but
this disjointed, disoriented, incongruent, context-lacking trash
pile didn't even properly follow through on its presumed ableism.
And that is a sentence I didn't think I'd be writing in my
lifetime.